- | 11:00 am
Trump’s ceasefire gamble tests fragile Middle East calm
As the truce nears expiry, diplomacy stalls, political pressures rise, and the risk of a wider war grows
At the time of writing on Monday, 20 April, as this unscripted tragedy continues, the key question is whether US President Donald Trump will extend the two-week ceasefire, which expires tomorrow, 21 April, and whether another round of talks will take place in Islamabad on that day.
If there is no extension, and no talks take place, the war will resume, with disastrous consequences not only for the three belligerents but also for the wider world, especially the Middle East. India has already felt the effects in several ways.
Only a few days ago, the prospects for a negotiated end to the war appeared brighter. After the inconclusive 21-hour talks in Islamabad, which ended early on 12 April, Pakistan resumed its mediation efforts.
Field Marshal Asim Munir travelled to Tehran on 15 April carrying proposals from the US, while Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif visited Saudi Arabia, Qatar, and Turkey.
The latest indications are that Iran is studying the US proposals and has not yet agreed to send a delegation to Islamabad, while Trump’s delegation, headed by Vice President J.D. Vance, is on its way.
Does Trump believe that by sending his delegation he can coerce Iran into talks?
He might be proved wrong, with disastrous consequences for all concerned.
By attacking and capturing an Iranian ship returning from China, Trump has not improved the chances of the talks taking place.
His repeated pronouncements make clear that he wants Iran to sign on the dotted line.
We do not know the contents of the proposals transmitted to Iran through Pakistan. What Iran appears to want is a framework for talks, not terms that can be read as an ultimatum.
In diplomacy, progress depends on agreement over a common draft that can then be refined through further consultations. In the present case, the belligerents are nowhere near that stage. Washington wants to dictate, and Tehran continues to resist.
Iran had assumed, perhaps with reason, that the two-week ceasefire that began on 8 April also covered Lebanon. Yet Tehran agreed to the Islamabad talks without insisting that the attacks stop before negotiations began.
Trump, for his part, recognized the need to stop the attacks on Lebanon. He compelled Israel to meet Lebanon at ambassadorial level in the presence of his secretary of state. These were the first official talks between the two countries in more than three decades.
The State Department then issued a statement saying the parties had agreed to a ceasefire. Trump invited, or rather summoned, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Lebanese President Joseph Aoun to the White House.
He then posted that he had “prohibited” Israel from carrying out further attacks on Lebanon, adding that “enough is enough”.
One might have thought Trump had finally decided to discipline Netanyahu. Instead, Netanyahu demonstrated his leverage by asking the Israel Defense Forces to resume attacks. Strangely, Trump did not ask him to stop. Rather, he praised Israel, “the great ally”, for its courage.
Part of the explanation may be Trump’s mercurial nature. But there may be more to it. The State Department statement had left Israel an option “to take all necessary measures in self-defense, at any time, against planned, imminent, or ongoing attacks”.
Netanyahu came under criticism from the far right for agreeing to the ceasefire, and he took time to spin the decision before speaking publicly.
In short, Trump’s claim that he had prohibited Israel from attacking Lebanon was never meant seriously. By acting as he did, he halted progress towards a second round of talks.
He also did so in another, more serious, way.
After the Israel-Lebanon ceasefire was announced, Iranian foreign minister Abbas Araghchi said on Friday, 17 April, that the Strait of Hormuz was open. Trump reposted this, implying that he deserved credit.
Soon after, however, he put out another post saying that the US naval blockade on ships travelling to or from Iranian ports would remain in place until a final settlement was reached. He had announced the blockade after the Islamabad talks ended without agreement.
In effect, the Strait of Hormuz could be used by all countries except Iran. To make matters worse, the US Central Command has captured an Iranian ship as mentioned above.
Hardliners in Tehran, including the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC), reacted sharply. They said the strait could be used only under terms laid down by Iran, including payment of fees and compliance with Iranian regulations.
The shipping industry was naturally thrown into confusion. The US Navy ordered ships to retrace their route. In the resulting disorder, two Indian ships came under fire from the IRGC, prompting India’s foreign secretary to summon the Iranian ambassador.
It is important for New Delhi to note that this does not appear to have been a case of the IRGC identifying the ships as Indian and then deciding to fire on them.
Given the rising political costs, how long can Trump continue the war?
Can he afford to resume the bombing of Iran when the war has already lasted 50 days, only 10 short of the point at which he would need congressional consent to continue military operations beyond 60 days under the 1973 War Powers Resolution?
A Democratic-led effort to constrain Trump’s ability to wage war with Iran was defeated in the House of Representatives on 17 April by 214 votes to 213. One Republican voted with the Democrats, and one Democrat voted with the Republicans.
We may see more such attempts. It is possible that a few more Republicans may join them. But Trump can veto any such resolution, and overriding Trump’s veto would require a two-thirds majority.
If Trump gets his way, Iran will surrender its 440 kilograms of enriched uranium to the US and pledge not to enrich uranium for the next 20 years, or perhaps somewhat less. In return, Trump would release Iran’s frozen funds and revoke sanctions. He would then have his family business, World Liberty Financial, strike deals with a sanctions-free Iran and make a fortune.
He would claim to have ended 47 years of hostility between Iran and the US while also saving Israel from a nuclear-armed Iran.
To the American Jewish Committee and the American Israeli Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC), he would claim that he had protected Israel by ensuring that Iran would never acquire a bomb, while preserving Israel’s nuclear monopoly in the region, apart from Pakistan, which has a defense treaty with Saudi Arabia.
A mature democracy is supposed to be self-correcting. The US, the world’s oldest democracy, will celebrate its 250th anniversary in July. Is today’s America still a self-correcting democracy? Clearly not. Congress and the judiciary have both failed to restrain Trump after he took the country to war without consulting Congress.
At present, defense secretary Pete Hegseth is being grilled in the Senate. Representative Yassamin Ansari, who is of Iranian origin, has taken the lead in moving to impeach Hegseth. The effort is likely to fail, as he still has the support of Republican members in the House.
The international community has a duty to act against an errant state that resorts to aggression except in self-defense or under a UN Security Council resolution.
The European Union and the United Kingdom have been sidelined by Trump and have been unable to get their act together. France and the UK chaired a hybrid meeting of 50 countries, of which about a dozen agreed to work on a non-military plan to secure the Strait of Hormuz. London is expected to take this forward.
It is clear, however, that London and Paris cannot do much that matters.
Angry at fellow NATO members for not sending their navies to assume control of the Strait of Hormuz, Trump has threatened to withdraw US troops from some European countries.
The Global South, led by India, the current chair of BRICS, and the Shanghai Cooperation Organization, dominated by China, has chosen to remain silent.
Russia and China, however, have been active. Both have criticized the aggression against Iran. It is believed that Russia supplied intelligence to Iran about the location of US military assets.
China has come out with a five-point plan with Pakistan, probably after consultations with Iran. At the same time, Chinese President Xi Jinping remains keen for Trump to visit him in May.
The Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) has looked divided and uncertain. The United Arab Emirates wants the war to continue, while others want a permanent ceasefire.
Has the GCC been chasing a mirage in accepting US bases in the belief that Washington is a reliable security provider?
It seems not to have imagined that the Pentagon could not protect it from Iranian drones and missiles. Washington never offered the Gulf states any air-defense system comparable to the Iron Dome it provided to Israel. Their request to Trump not to allow US bases in the region to be used for attacks on Iran was ignored.
When I was ambassador in Qatar from 1992 to 1997, it was already clear that the Qatari government had little say over what took place at the US air base there.
What happens now?
Trump is desperate for a deal and wants to go to Islamabad once one is reached.
Netanyahu wants to resume the war, postpone the hearings on corruption charges against him, and advance his Greater Israel project by dismembering or destabilizing Iran.
The key question, then, is who prevails, Trump or Netanyahu.
Iran, for its part, wants a deal, but is not desperate for one.
This war, though regional for now, already has global consequences, from shortages of cooking gas and export losses to supply-chain disruption and possible jet fuel shortages in Europe that could trigger flight cancellations, to name only a few.
The UN Development Programme has estimated that if the war is prolonged, 32.5 million people could fall below the poverty line.
One can only hope that Trump prevails over Netanyahu and that Iran plays the diplomatic chessboard adroitly.



