- | 3:30 pm
Why Trump’s war logic is the real danger
Trump’s claims of victory and ceasefire diplomacy deserve closer scrutiny as the Iran war strains the global economy and narrows India’s diplomatic room.
To the relief of the global citizen, US President Donald Trump and first lady Melania Trump escaped unhurt from what appears to have been an attempt on his life at the White House Correspondents’ Association dinner.
It is an added relief that none of those attending the event was injured. A Secret Service official was wounded, but is reported to be out of danger.
The suspect has been identified as Cole Tomas Allen, 31, a Caltech graduate from the Los Angeles area. The judicial process is under way, and we still do not know what precisely motivated him.
Trump addressed a hastily called White House press conference after the incident with admirable composure. He compared himself to Abraham Lincoln, who was assassinated after the Union victory in the Civil War, and argued that only “consequential” leaders are targeted by “sick minds.”
Asked whether Iran had any link to the attack, Trump initially said there was none. Later, he said, “We will find out.”
It is important that no link is fabricated if there is none. Even a manufactured connection could give Trump apparent justification for resuming the war against Iran, with or without congressional approval.
Trump has claimed that the attempt on his life will not deter him from seeking victory in the war on Iran. We can agree that he is entitled to seek victory. The more important question is what victory means.
Victory in this case should mean resolving the dispute through diplomatic negotiations, not bombing Iran into another Gaza, whose reconstruction alone is estimated by the United Nations to cost about $70 billion.
Victory cannot mean destroying an ancient civilization or sending Iran back to “the Stone Age,” as Trump once boasted. It cannot mean destroying every bridge and power plant in Iran. It cannot mean a reckless attempt to seize the 440 kg of enriched uranium, which Trump has called “nuclear dust,” buried deep in Isfahan or elsewhere. It cannot mean pushing Iran to walk out of the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty and secretly decide to build a bomb.
Trump claims to be a follower of Christ, the Prince of Peace. As a candidate, he promised his fellow citizens that he, unlike his predecessors, would not drag the country into wars.
His claim to have brought ceasefires to as many as 10 conflicts does not stand scrutiny. His claim that he mediated an end to the India-Pakistan air conflict, known in India as Operation Sindoor, in May last year has been rejected by India.
His latest claim is that he has secured a ceasefire between Israel and Lebanon. That claim, too, requires scrutiny.
Trump first compelled Israel and Lebanon to meet officially after decades without such contact, at the level of ambassadors, with US secretary of state Marco Rubio mediating. A 10-day ceasefire was announced on 16 April. He later arranged further meetings, and the ceasefire was extended by three weeks on 23 April.
Yet since the ceasefire was announced, Israel has continued to bomb Lebanon under the pretext of fighting Hezbollah. Before and after Trump announced the three-week extension, Israeli strikes continued. Trump has been largely silent on Israel’s violations, except once when he said he had “ordered” Israel to comply with the ceasefire. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has ignored that order.
Technically, Israel and Lebanon are not at war. It was therefore something of a charade to have the two states agree to a ceasefire while the real belligerents are the Israel Defense Forces and Hezbollah, often described in the West as an Iranian proxy.
That description is wrong. Hezbollah’s founders were inspired by Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini, who overthrew the Shah in 1979. But Hezbollah was established in the 1980s to fight the Israeli occupation of parts of Lebanon after the 1982 invasion. If Israel had not invaded Lebanon in 1982 and occupied Lebanese territory, there would have been no Hezbollah.
I have visited Hezbollah’s office in Beirut and was impressed by its library. The organization draws its strength from Lebanon’s Shias, who account for roughly a third of the population and form the country’s largest single community.
As of now, there is no sign of another round of talks in Islamabad.
The consequences for the global economy are already visible. S&P Global surveys show the euro zone’s composite purchasing managers’ index (PMI) fell from 50.7 in March to 48.6 in April, moving from marginal expansion into contraction. In PMI surveys, readings above 50 indicate growth, while readings below 50 signal a decline in activity.
The pressure was sharper in services, the bloc’s largest sector, where the index fell to 47.4 from 50.2, also crossing from expansion into contraction. At the same time, the input price index jumped to 76.9 from 68.9, showing a steep rise in production costs for European businesses.
The corresponding numbers for the US economy are better. The US PMI rose to 54 in April from 52.3 in March. But Chris Williamson of S&P Global has warned that “the uptick in the headline US readings was hardly indicative of a bustling economy.”
The International Monetary Fund has cut its global growth outlook to 3.1% for this year and warned that the world could drift toward a more adverse scenario, including outright recession, if the disruptions continue.
The Global South, which accounts for almost 85% of humanity, will suffer more than the richer North. In Thailand, people have been advised to work from home and avoid lifts. Rice producers in Vietnam, Myanmar and the Philippines are facing fertilizer shortages.
South Asia has been hit hard. India, Pakistan and Bangladesh import most of the oil they need. All three will also face pressure from falling remittances from the Gulf.
On 27 February, the day before Israel and the US attacked Iran, India’s ministry of finance had described the economy as being in a “Goldilocks” moment of high growth and low inflation, projecting growth of 7% to 7.4% for 2027. That outlook now needs revision.
Gulf energy companies, including Qatar Energy, Kuwait Petroleum and Bapco (Bahrain), have declared force majeure, and their exports of fuel and fertilizer to India will be affected. India sources a large share of its ammonia, sulphur and diammonium phosphate requirements from the Gulf, including Saudi Arabia.
About 22,000 workers have returned from the Gulf, and many still there have lost jobs. Reliable statistics are not yet available. But remittances from the Gulf, estimated at about $55 billion a year, are likely to fall.
There is also a diplomatic cost. India’s policy began with almost total support for Israel, with no statement issued after Israel assassinated Iran’s supreme leader or the killing of over 150 school girls.
Iran wanted a statement from India as chair of BRICS on the situation in West Asia. A BRICS meeting of deputy ministers held in Delhi on 23 and 24 April failed to produce a communique. BRICS foreign ministers are scheduled to meet on 14 and 15 May to prepare for the summit in September.
India has corrected its policy of total support for Israel, but timidly and too slowly. A more vigorous correction is required. India could have issued a statement urging all concerned to abide by international law and the UN Charter after Iran’s supreme leader was assassinated. Studied silence appeared to imply support for Israel’s act.
Netanyahu sold Trump the Mossad assessment that with the killing of the supreme leader and others at the top, combined with sustained bombing, Iran would surrender or the regime would collapse. Did Israel try to sell the same assessment to India?
Pakistan may or may not succeed in its diplomatic mediation. India should feel no discomfort if it does. India, too, will benefit immensely if Pakistan succeeds.
Pakistan has represented Iran’s interests in Washington since 1992. It was chosen by Trump for reasons well known.
India needs to introspect on whether its policy of projecting Pakistan as the epicenter of terrorism has succeeded. The answer may not be as clear as New Delhi would like.



